Follow Us

Closing early for Thanksgiving

Today we are going to be closing the shop a little early in observance of Thanksgiving. We will be open until 3:00 p.m. today, closed all day tomorrow and opening early on Friday. Friday we will be opening at 8:00 a.m. and staying open until 8:00 p.m.  We hope you enjoy the company of your friends and family. If you are traveling, travel safely. Eat lots of turkey, stuffing, and potatos!



New items available on our Etsy page!

We are creating up a storm here at The Gift Itself. There are new pieces being added to our Etsy page at :

You can find all kinds of one of kind, hand made and uniqe jewelry items which are perfect for any occasion. Keep in mind that we can alway make something just for you. 

All you have to do is let us know! We frequently create custom jewelry that is inspired by pieces we have already done or something completly new that is made using your

ideas! Just message us at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. and let us know.



There are so many pieces of new art here!!

Alright!! I admit it, I'm a nerd for the arts!! There, I said it, now enjoy more photos of awesome new art that our artists have produced. Included in the following photos is a super cute new jumper that Mary Sue Fenner made, temari balls (ancient Japanese toys) by local artist Sally Cubitt, and holiday ornaments from Barb and Doug Henderson out of Sturgeon Bay.

One of our watercolor artists, Stacey Small brought in new greeting cards with beautiful original works of art on each card. We are going to have new work from one of our old favorites, Rollin Karg who does glorious blown glass sculptures. 

Also, don't forget about Draw-lery by previous owner Michelle Zjala Winter. Get your orders in sooner rather than later for the coming holiday season. Stop in with your childs drawings and she will turn them into wearable pieces of jewelry in silver or gold. She did just finish a new collection of jewelry for us including evergreen trees in silver, accenting natural gemstones. 

There is so much going on down here, we can't even get all the info out quick enough to share. Stop on down to check it all out. Enjoy this beautiful fall day and we look forward to seeing you all soon!

Below are the fused glass pieces by Bard and Doug Henderson


Mary Sue Fenner clothing and David Kwasny painting




Sally Cubitt Temari Balls


Glass and metal scupltures from Rollin Karg

Watercolor cards (among others) and don't forget about "Draw-Lery" by Michelle Zjala Winter for the upcoming holiday!


Natural gemstone accented with a silver evergreen tree by Michelle Zjala Winter.


Closing early on October 6th

Hello, everyone!

The Gift Itself will be closing at 1:00 on Monday, October 6th due to a wedding! Thank you all for your understanding!


Last Farmer's Market Tonight!

Well, folks, summer is officially over, which means the last farmer's market of the season is tonight! While it's a bummer to see those super fun evenings on Broadway come to a close for the year, it sounds like tonight will be quite the celebration- we are going out with a bang!

The Gift Itself will be open tonight until 7:00, so please stop in and say hello! We have updated the floor plan of the store and gotten new work in from one of our wonderful fiber artists, Mary Sue Fenner. In addition, we have been producing new work like crazy, so there's lots of new jewelry to check out! After checking out the new work at the store, why not stick around on the street? This evening the market will be open until 10:00, and The Cougars, a local favorite band, will be performing!

We would like to thank all our wonderful customers for supporting the Farmer's Market on Broadway! I think we can all agree that it's truly a one-of-a-kind event for a one-of-a-kind district! It promises to be a very exciting and fun night- we definitely recommend you don't miss it!